Skip to main content

A Moral Dilemma Then & Now

History is part of us even when we are unaware of it. I’d been living in and hiking around the Foothills for years without knowing much about the complex factors that shaped the history of this heavily forested area. I set out to learn more about what has brought us to the perilous wildfire conditions of the present moment. With the Caldor Fire of 2021 taking out more than 200 homes and 250,000 acres, and the increase of mega-fires across California generally, wildfire brings a strong connection to grief around the disruption of family life, the loss of generations of trees, damage to soil and wildlife, and release of masses of carbon. What historical forces might be relevant to understand where we are now?


The forest holds a history that can explain our current state.


Last fall I had a conversation with Tony Valdez, an energetic rock climber and passionate storyteller who worked for 37 years with the US Forest Service. Tony lent me his copy of the book by Timothy Egan, The Big Burn. It recounts circumstances around the 1910 wildfire in Northwest Montana and Idaho in which more than three millions acres burned. Whole towns were lost, and teams of brave forest rangers were overcome. This catastrophic event played a pivotal role in U.S. policy on public lands.


Around the time of this Big Burn, the foremost visionary for conservation, John Muir, diverged philosophically from Gifford Pinchot, the first official Chief of the U.S. Forest Service and wrestling buddy of Teddy Roosevelt. A great moral dilemma for the nation emerged around what to do with public or what was perceived as "unclaimed" lands. Some argued for saving the forests for future generations. Others represented powerful forces of American industry including timber extraction and railroads. They argued that government agencies must protect national land for profit-turning purposes, and in keeping with this mindset, that the responsibility of the Forest Service was then deemed to suppress fire.


The policy of fire suppression instituted at that time is a link in a struggle that continues to the present day.


Many people's lives are connected to the forest. I am deeply moved by the dedicated efforts and risks taken by foresters, first responders, and firefighters, and am deeply respectful of the traditional Indigenous approach to integrating fire holistically for forest health. Our local land stewardship efforts are examples of solutions in action, as are the findings of scientists about soil and plant recovery after wildfire. I have grief as well as anger about the impacts of environmental neglect and greed, yet people need sustainable livelihoods. It seems an impossible task to manage such competing factors.


Ultimately, our story is about the collision of land and fire, especially for those living on the wildland-urban interface, or WUI. In this zone, structures and human activities meet and intermingle with undeveloped land and vegetative fuels.


Our upcoming art and music exploration is about coming together to grieve, heal, and reflect on our shared history. On knowing that we have created the current conditions. On how we might possibly work toward a safer, healthier forest, by using fire. On calling in the spirits and ghosts who inhabit the land to hear their songs.


-- Ameera Godwin, Co-Founder and Artistic Director, Myrtle Tree Arts



FIRE/LAND

An Experience Inspiring Community Resilience

Saturday, June 10th, 2023, 4PM - 10PM

Wakamatsu Farm, 941 Cold Springs Road, Placerville, CA 95667


A project of Myrtle Tree Arts and co-hosted by the American River Conservancy, this unique "art rock opera for the forest" and public forum will happen at the landmark Wakamatsu Farm. During the speaker forum in the late afternoon, local experts and representatives will share community issues related to wildfire, land stewardship, emergency preparedness, cultural preservation, and forest ecology. The evening features Main Street Collective's Pink Floyd Dark Side of the Moon 50th Anniversary concert followed by FIRE/LAND: Knowing the Territory, a musical and dramatic performance starring musicians, singers, Native American storyteller, and video projections in a creative exploration of wildfire, ecological change, and resilience in El Dorado County. This intellectual and creative experience strives to spark inspiration and your call to action in support of community resilience! 
See more details on the Myrtle Tree Arts Fire/Land page.


FIRE/LAND: The Exhibition

SWITCHBOARD GALLERY

Arts and Culture El Dorado 

525 Main St. Placerville, CA

June 8 - August 6, 2023

 

Experience this installation of Ameera Godwin's digital prints and video from FIRE/LAND.

Artist Talk, July 13th, 6pm 

 

 

FIRE/LAND is made possible with support from:

The Latrobe Fund, Sacramento Region Community Foundation,
Pure Life/Sacred Roots, in partnership with the
American River Conservancy and Arts and Culture El Dorado


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

RIPE AREA: Renewing Relationships with Water Through Art

RIPE AREA is a play on the term "riparia", the land adjacent to and influenced by water. The waters of the South Fork of American River tumble downstream in the crush of ice melt, rushing in currents, propelled by dam releases, and slowing along sandy flatlands. Wet, fluid fingers fan out among cattails, quietly seeping into sodden ground.  Over time, h umans have changed the river, eroded its banks, mined its tributaries, drained its meadows, and farmed its floodplains. The waters of the South Fork of the American River , for example, are contained by t hree major reservoirs and other smaller man-made reservoirs  El Dorado County. The major dams are  at  Slab Creek Reservoir built in 1967, Chili Bar Reservoir built in 1964 and Folsom Lake Reservoir built in 1955 .  Headwaters of the South Fork of the American River collect in high-altitude Lake Audrain, captured in the image I created, above, for the music and underwater sound art installation, Music for 33 Dr...
Post a Comment
Read more

Ramparts: Centrum Artist Residency, Part 2

Arriving at Fort Worden sent me on a hunt about fortification history and architecture. Following trails through the woods to the top of Artillery Hill, Paul and I encounter the ramparts, solidly built gun emplacements known here as “batteries.” “Bulwark” is another term that feels related to the work from my first week at Centrum: large pencil drawings of entangled old growth cedar and spruce branches and roots. The “bul-” part of bulwark is related to bole, “tree trunk,” while -wark is related to English work, wrought, and wright.  The last of the guns at the fort were removed in 1945, and the defunct battery enclosures, tunnels, stairwells, rusting doors and pipes, lichen-stained concrete, a stately sign with the name, Cornelius Tolles, a captain who died from his wounds in a Civil War battle—comprise these eerie tombs. We start to hymn and sing into the dark reverberating chambers. “What a performance venue!”, our eyes circling in their sockets as we imagine the possibilities....
Post a Comment
Read more

Life After Smoke and Char

A recent classroom-based workshop on Prescribed Burning was my first immersion into learning about fire behavior and concepts rooted in science, law, and practice on the ground. Beneficial Disturbance. Heat Management. F.R.I. for Fire Return Interval. Learning about burning and its connections to culture and biodiversity was a first step toward overcoming my own negative perceptions about fire.  The course was led by experts Chris Paulus and Cordi Craig of Placer County, and coordinated by Kestrel Grevatt and the American River Conservancy, and emphasized the benefits of careful, legal burning. We were introduced to fuels and forest types, fire and wind behavior, state statutes and personal liabilities, Indigenous cultural burning and native plant adaptation. The experience was surprisingly rich.   “The forest has memory,” announced Chris, a well-spoken and commanding retired CAL FIRE Battalion Captain. “The forest has to be allowed to remember itself.” I’m going to borr...
1 comment
Read more